• Critical-Hits Studios
    • Criminals Card Game
    • Sentinel Comics: the Roleplaying Game
  • Downloads & Tools
    • Critical Hits Fantasy Name Generator
    • Drinking D&D 2010
    • Drinking D&D 2011
    • Fiasco Playset: “Alma Monster”
    • MODOK’s 11 for Marvel Heroic Roleplaying
    • Refuge In Audacity RPG
    • Strange New Worlds RPG
  • Guides
    • Gamma World
    • Guide to 4e Accessories
    • Guide to Gaming DVDs
    • Skill Challenges
  • RSS Feed
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Critical Hits

Everything tabletop gaming since 2005

  • News
  • Reviews
  • Columns
    • Dire Flailings
    • Dungeonomics
    • Musings of the Chatty DM
    • Pain of Publication
    • The Architect DM
  • Podcasts
    • Critical Hits Podcast
    • Dungeon Master Guys Podcast
  • Roleplaying Games
  • Tabletop Games
  • Game Hacks & Content
  • Video Games

Zen and the Art of Dungeon Mastering #3: Mind Your Players’ Styles, Part 3 of 4

July 11, 2012 by The Chatty DM

In part one, I broached how DMs had to be take into account their players’ motivations to play RPGs in order to keep them interested and involved in a prolonged campaign. In part two, I talked about three categories of motivators: Power Gaming, Butt-Kicking and Tactics.  In this post, I’ll tackle Specialty, Method Acting and the much discussed, often misunderstood, Storytelling.

Specialty

Specialist players are sending you a very loud and clear message about what they want out of your game. It’s not just  “Drows Rangers Rock.” They want their characters to play a significant role within the group and they want to look as cool as possible while doing it. While this can be easy for those who play decked out min-maxed ranged-based rangers, things aren’t always as easy for those who insist on playing sub-optimal/weird characters like mute bards specializing in tribal belly dancing.

Yes, I’ve seen those.

To make a specialist feel… Well, special, you should

  • Set encounters that appeals or calls to the uniqueness of the character. Cat Ninjas need to infiltrate castles and Mime Bards need to… Hmm… Act as distractions while mobs of angry NPCs try to lynch them
  • Build the origins of the character (or his clan/family/race… etc) into one of the key plots of your campaign
  • Have at least one short to mid term Crowning Moment of Awesome planned for the character. Foreshadow it  more  the further down the planned timeline you place it
You should not
  • Make the player feel his character is useless, stupid or unoriginal. Preference in characters is one of those “eye of the beholder” things
  • Create or impose setting elements that invalidate the existence of the character. The classic “Setting canon trumps what you want” is an unfortunate, if classic, argument you should avoid. Work with the player to make what they want work within your establish setting.

Method Acting

Players in this broad category are around the table to explore, play out and tell the story of their characters from an inner perspective. They may want to speak in character. They will play impossibly weird character combinations. They will likely relish having to surmount terrible obstacles that will make their PCs grow, not so much in power but as fully-fleshed characters.

If the table’s a stage and you have Method Actors sitting at it, you should

  • Enforce tolerance and patience in yourself and other to let players get really into their characters a few times and accept weird, uncomfortable character concepts (Cross-Gender, Gay, Religious… etc).
  • Tweak some scenes where your story and the character motivation meet, or better yet, clash violently.
  • Force unbearable moral and characterial choices on players and let them wade in the ensuing drama

You should not

  • Allow such players to hog the spotlight. A 2 min soliloquy is fine, a 15 minute requiem for a dead NPC isin’t… unless everyone really liked that NPC
  • Unnecessarily interrupt the players in mid-sentence or make fun of them for speaking in character. Manage the spotlight, don’t be a tyrant about it.

Storytelling

This is likely the biggest contention between DMs and players. To many DMs, roleplaying and storytelling  are synonymous and equivalent. It isn’t. I’ll make sure to dedicate a whole post on just that very soon.

Players who prefer storytelling want their characters to be part of something  greater than the sum of their adventures. They want to see a world live and breathe around them. This includes players who love to explore for new lore and legends. Where DMs and players often diverge on that point is that players want to be THE main players of that world whereas DMs may consider the worlds they made to be the main characters. Players don’t want to feel like some insignificant worker bee whose job is to act as a glorified Fed Ex service.

If you have Storytellers gathered around your fire, you should

  • Make every encounter play a significant role in the larger story. You need to be able to explain why anything happens in regards to your plots
  • Make most NPCs, even those involved in combat, have goals, fears and a general outlook that storytellers can discover and exploit. Be ready to invent them for minor, nameless NPCs, you never know
  • Make the characters integral, fundamental part of the plot. Make them lost princes, disowned lords or descendants of spiteful tyrants

You should not

  • Chain together combat encounters with generic opponents. They need more complex motivations  than “guard this room”
  • Drop PCs into a dungeon without it having a clear link to a larger story or several areas of exploration that give insight to the setting or the campaign’s plots.

Up next: Watching/Lurking, Instigating and a secret bonus

Share This:

  • Tweet
  • Share on Tumblr
  • Email
  • Print

Filed Under: Featured, Roleplaying Games, Science Fiction & Fantasy Genre Tagged With: advice, D&D, DM, DMing, DMing Advice, dungeon master, Zen and the Art of DMing

Comments

  1. S'mon says

    July 11, 2012 at 5:24 pm

    IME setting up a ‘crowning moment of awesome’ is about the most dangerous thing a GM can do. It requires the player to Step On Up and actually Be Awesome. If they see your set-piece, curl up and Turtle, it turns into a massive disaster.

    Have you read http://monstersandmanuals.blogspot.co.uk/2012/02/you-are-responsible-for-your-own-orgasm.html ? In general I think that creating the conditions where players can create their own Moments of Awesome is a better approach to trying to cater specifically to player desires through heavy scripting.

  2. Tom's says

    August 7, 2012 at 11:13 am

    Hi.

    I think there should be a distinction in the Storytelling type.

    We should distinguish between the ones who want to PARTICIPATE in a greater story, like you watch a great TV show, like in a more or less preplaned campaign storyline, and the ones who want to BUILD a great story, open-ended to the end, which is IMHO what makes our hobby so unique.

    It’s a huge difference that can radically changes the GM’s behavior, from a director role to a open-ended situations broker one.

    I don’t know how you can put that in your typology :
    – architects and audience ?
    – disruptors and collaborators ?
    – Storyliving and storybuilding ?

About the Author

  • The Chatty DM

    The Chatty DM is the "nom de plume" of gamer geek Philippe-Antoine Menard. He has been a GM for over 40 years. An award-winning RPG blogger, game designer, and scriptwriter at Ubisoft. He squats a corner of Critical Hits he affectionately calls "Musings of the Chatty DM." (Email Phil or follow him on Twitter.)

    Email: chattydm@critical-hits.comWeb: https://critical-hits.com//category/chattydm/

Subscribe

RSS Feed

Archives

CC License

All articles and comments posted posted on the site (but not the products for sale) are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 3.0 United States License. References to trademarks and copywritten material are included for review and commentary use only and are not intended as any kind of challenge.

Recent Comments

  • fogus: The best things and stuff of 2024 on Remembering the Master: An Inelegant Eulogy for Kory Heath
  • Routinely Itemised: RPGs #145 on Review: The Magus
  • The Chatty DM on Review: The Magus
  • Linnaeus on Review: The Magus
  • 13th Age: Indexing Truths — Critical Hits on The Horizon Conspiracy

Contact The Staff

Critical Hits staff can be reached via the contact information on their individual staff pages and in their articles. If you want to reach our senior staff, email staff @ critical-hits.com. We get sent a lot of email, so we can't promise we'll be able to respond to everything.

Recent Posts

  • Remembering the Master: An Inelegant Eulogy for Kory Heath
  • Review: The Magus
  • Hope in the Dark Heart of Evil is Not a Plan
  • Chatty on Games #1: Dorf Romantik
  • The Infinity Current: Adventure 0

Top Posts & Pages

  • Home
  • The 5x5 Method Compendium
  • Dungeons & Dragons "Monster Manual" Preview: The Bulette!
  • Critical Hits Fantasy Name Generator
  • On Mid-Medieval Economics, Murder Hoboing and 100gp
  • "The Eversink Post Office" - An Unofficial Supplement for Swords of the Serpentine
  • Finally a manual for the rest of them!
  • Dave Chalker AKA Dave The Game
  • How to Compare Birds to Fish
  • The Incense War: a Story of Price Discovery, Mayhem, and Lust

Copyright © 2025 · News Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in