• Critical-Hits Studios
    • Criminals Card Game
    • Sentinel Comics: the Roleplaying Game
  • Downloads & Tools
    • Critical Hits Fantasy Name Generator
    • Drinking D&D 2010
    • Drinking D&D 2011
    • Fiasco Playset: “Alma Monster”
    • MODOK’s 11 for Marvel Heroic Roleplaying
    • Refuge In Audacity RPG
    • Strange New Worlds RPG
  • Guides
    • Gamma World
    • Guide to 4e Accessories
    • Guide to Gaming DVDs
    • Skill Challenges
  • RSS Feed
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Critical Hits

Everything tabletop gaming since 2005

  • News
  • Reviews
  • Columns
    • Dire Flailings
    • Dungeonomics
    • Musings of the Chatty DM
    • Pain of Publication
    • The Architect DM
  • Podcasts
    • Critical Hits Podcast
    • Dungeon Master Guys Podcast
  • Roleplaying Games
  • Tabletop Games
  • Game Hacks & Content
  • Video Games

From the Archives: Skills

February 17, 2011 by Dave

I’m trying a new experiment today, taking a recent topic and providing links to some articles in our extensive archives (over 5 years has produced over 2000 posts). If you enjoy this kind of article, let me know in comments.

Today I’m looking at skills. Rob Schwalb’s article about his dissatisfaction with them mirrors many of my concerns that have existed ever since my very first game of 3rd edition up through my current campaign. However, they clearly have value, as you’ll see in many of these posts, but also can pose some issues.

3 Rolls, 1 Check
Wherein I pinpoint one of my big issues with the D&D skill mechanics.

But my father was a blacksmith! – Crafting in 4e
A guest post on the old ChattyDM blog by A Hero Twice A Month about using skill challenges for crafting.

Rewarding the Risks
An article by Scott Wallace where he outlines a skill system that heavily tries to balance risks and rewards by making categories of success.

4th Power Project: Skills
My ultimately failed d20 modern adaptation for 4e, this post just amused me when comparing my list to the one in Gamma World.

Primal/Within: City of the Overmind
ChattyDM took a group of quests within a city and connected them to player goals. Accomplishing them required skill checks, but tackled in a way inspired by Mouse Guard so that failing a skill check wasn’t a blocker, it just introduced more complications into the adventure. Check out the entire Primal/Within chronicles for more examples of this.

Air War: A Skill Challenge
One of the things I’ve talked about lately with a few people is running a successful skill challenge at higher levels. Air War is a description of one that I ran for my campaign that remains one of the skill challenges I have enjoyed the most in my campaign.

Skill Challenges
Of course, our most popular guide contains all kinds of great links to skill challenges and skill usage advice in 4e.

The Power of Shared Data
A guest post by me over on At-Will, I came up with a system to combat some of the behaviors in skill use that annoy me – and then the commenters came up with better ideas. So it goes!

Share This:

  • Tweet
  • Share on Tumblr
  • Email
  • Print

Filed Under: Editorial Tagged With: 4e, from the archives, skill challenges, skills

About Dave

Dave "The Game" Chalker is the Editor-in-Chief and Co-Founder of Critical Hits. Since 2005, he has been bringing readers game news and advice, as well as editing nearly everything published here. He is the designer of the Origins Award-winning Get Bit!, a freelance designer and developer, son of a science fiction author, and a Master of Arts. He lives in MD with e and at least three dogs.

Comments

  1. Wyatt says

    February 17, 2011 at 9:27 pm

    I think this is a pretty excellent idea. It gives me a lot of stuff I might not have read (or might need a refresher course on) and you can pretty easily use it to lead in to new articles later on. Quite helpful and I’d find more of these agreeable.

About the Author

  • Dave

    Dave "The Game" Chalker is the Editor-in-Chief and Co-Founder of Critical Hits. Since 2005, he has been bringing readers game news and advice, as well as editing nearly everything published here. He is the designer of the Origins Award-winning Get Bit!, a freelance designer and developer, son of a science fiction author, and a Master of Arts. He lives in MD with e and at least three dogs.

    Email: dave@critical-hits.com

    Follow me:

Subscribe

RSS Feed

Archives

CC License

All articles and comments posted posted on the site (but not the products for sale) are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 3.0 United States License. References to trademarks and copywritten material are included for review and commentary use only and are not intended as any kind of challenge.
Mastodon

Recent Comments

  • fogus: The best things and stuff of 2024 on Remembering the Master: An Inelegant Eulogy for Kory Heath
  • Routinely Itemised: RPGs #145 on Review: The Magus
  • The Chatty DM on Review: The Magus
  • Linnaeus on Review: The Magus
  • 13th Age: Indexing Truths — Critical Hits on The Horizon Conspiracy

Contact The Staff

Critical Hits staff can be reached via the contact information on their individual staff pages and in their articles. If you want to reach our senior staff, email staff @ critical-hits.com. We get sent a lot of email, so we can't promise we'll be able to respond to everything.

Recent Posts

  • Remembering the Master: An Inelegant Eulogy for Kory Heath
  • Review: The Magus
  • Hope in the Dark Heart of Evil is Not a Plan
  • Chatty on Games #1: Dorf Romantik
  • The Infinity Current: Adventure 0

Top Posts & Pages

  • Home
  • The 5x5 Method Compendium
  • Dungeons & Dragons "Monster Manual" Preview: The Bulette!
  • Critical Hits Fantasy Name Generator
  • On Mid-Medieval Economics, Murder Hoboing and 100gp
  • "The Eversink Post Office" - An Unofficial Supplement for Swords of the Serpentine
  • Finally a manual for the rest of them!
  • Dave Chalker AKA Dave The Game
  • How to Compare Birds to Fish
  • The Incense War: a Story of Price Discovery, Mayhem, and Lust

Copyright © 2025 · News Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in